Thanks for your reply :-)
Right. It’s not that we don’t want to help, but we have to limit our scope of support in these forums so that we have time to assist site owners who are paying us for support services. I’ll try to answer this in the context of a Pre-Sale question (i.e. as a question about features or functionality), but I can’t offer debugging assistance here.
I am a newbie to S2member but have been using WP for some time. I have set up a site that requires areas to have limited access. So far everything is working well other than one page which I seem to be unable to protect. It is a kind of portfolio listing/thumbnail page. I have set this to be protected but it still shows if you aren’t logged in. I think the issue is because the page content is called in somehow by the theme as you have to set this page in the theme options as that for the portfolio. I hope that makes sense as I know it’s a little complicated.
s2Member (even the free version), comes with a feature called “URI Restrictons”. Any Post/Page (or some other type of content) that is declassified as a Post/Page/Category/Tag/etc (as you mentioned your theme is doing with a specific Page that it assigns to some other aspect of your site), you will need to protect that content using a URI Restriction with s2Member; because when it’s declassified by your theme and served up differently on-site, WordPress does not consider it a Post/Page any longer. That is, it’s not served as a Post/Page, it’s served as something slightly different, by your theme in this case.
See: Dashboard -› s2Member® -› Restriction Options -› URI Access Restrictions
See also: Video » s2Member (Content Restriction Trouble?)