Page Access Restriction Problems

Hi Guys,

When a level 0 subscriber logs in to my site, they go to what should be a restricted page, but instead get the fully paid members page.
I have the page number as being restricted to level 1 (paid up members) so I simply can’t see what has gone wrong

I’m literally pulling my hair out, and I know it will be something so stupid i’m gonna kick myself, but I really am struggling with this.

My subscribers are laughing of course because they get free information at the moment.

Please help