Profile Canceled

We have our site set up to accept 4 different payments.

1 month, 7 files, $5 non-recurring
1 month 17 files, $12 non-recurring
1 year 84 files, $48 non-recurring
1 year, 204 files, $116 on-recurring

I set up buttons for these.
[s2Member-PayPal-Button level="1" ccaps="" desc="Monthly Limited (7 files) / description and pricing details here." ps="paypal" lc="" cc="USD" dg="0" ns="1" custom="ourwebsite" ta="0" tp="0" tt="D" ra="5" rp="1" rt="M" rr="0" rrt="" rra="1" image="default" output="button" /]

I’ll offer the first 0 days @ $0
Then, I want to charge: $5 One Time (for 1 month access, non-recurring)

Here is what is happening though.

I end up having 3 notations in PayPal.

Sep 1, 2013 – Recurring Payment From – CUSTOMER 1 – Created
Sep 1, 2013 – Recurring Payment From – CUSTOMER 1 – Expired
Sep 1, 2013 – Recurring Payment From – CUSTOMER 1 – Completed – $5.00

I then get an email from PayPal (which I’m assuming the customer does as well)

Profile Canceled

Hello,

You successfully canceled the following PayPal Recurring Payment profile. We will no longer bill the buyer. If you did not request this cancellation, contact PayPal Customer Support toll-free at 1-888-221-1161.

Profile ID: ###
Invoice Number: ##
For: Monthly Limited (7 files) / description and pricing details here.
Buyer Name: CUSTOMER 1
Buyer Email: email
Payment Details

Start Date: Sep 1, 2013
Payment Cycle: Monthly
Amount Per Cycle: $5.00 USD
Last Payment Date: Sep 1, 2013
Last Payment Amount: $5.00 USD

This is happening with every single customer who orders.

I tried to change the buttons to Buy Now – non-recurring & no trial but I have open registration closed, so when they come back from PayPal, it restricts them from registering on the site AND keeps their money without refunding it.

I have tested the order process out myself. There were no failures, or hiccups with my order but it did the same automatically with my order. I received 2 emails for my purchase

You set up an automatic payment profile
Hello,

You just set up an automatic payment profile to Gotta Pixel Pixel Club. Here’s the information:

---

Hello,

You successfully canceled the following PayPal Recurring Payment profile.

—
Why is it setting up a recurring payment when I specifically state that it is NOT a recurring payment?

I still need a response on this please. I am a Pro user.