I am having a similar problem. I contacted Go Daddy, my host, and they told me that I can’t send emails from within my site from a free email address (I was using gmail). We changed my email to one provided by Go Daddy (@joeraciti.com address) and ran a test. The Go Daddy support person had updated my @joeraciti.com email address to send a copy to my gmail address and when we ran the test I did in fact receive an email. However, when I tried to purchase a membership using a friend’s paypal account, my friend never received a confirmation email with login details and instead was sent to a page on my site at (joeraciti.com/?s2member_paypal_return=1) – actually, there was a bunch of other stuff after that link but I get the same page when I just plug that in. The page that I see is:
[ joeraciti.com ] says…
Thank you! ( you MUST check your email before proceeding ).
* Note: It can take ( up to 15 minutes ) for Email Confirmation with important details. If you don’t receive email confirmation in the next 15 minutes, please contact Support.
Back To Home Page
If you need assistance, please contact support
I installed the server checker file that I found linked to in another s2member forum and ran the server check test in Google Chrome. I copied the output into a notepad file. You can read that here: https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B71IVUXzSG2JVXBZVEs5b1BkSk0/edit
Thank you kindly.
– Joe